Mother's Day ❤️ Click here to get 4 FREE glasses 🎁͏

Jug water filter

carafe filtrante

Many of you use a carafe filter in your home, and you have questions about how it works.

We will try to answer them, without entering into a scientific debate that is already widely available.

At the bottom of this article, you will find links to a very complete study carried out by ANSES and another carried out by the association "Que choisir".

A carafe filter is composed of a container with a double tank, the upper part is made to receive the water to be filtered, the lower part to store the filtered water.

In the middle there is a plastic filter, which is usually changed every month or after 100 litres of filtered water.

Here are the contents of the filter of a carafe filter:

cartouche carafe filtrante

The white beads are ion exchange resins, the black ones are activated carbon, all wrapped in plastic, and enriched with silver particles to prevent bacterial growth in the filter.

As for coffee pods, it is very difficult to recycle, except by paying a lot of money for a specific process, because of the mix of components, and the low value of the materials.

The water you pour into the top tank of the carafe filter will therefore pass by gravity through these balls (it takes several minutes and it must be done in several times) into the bottom tank. Filter carafes are not airtight and therefore require some precautions for their use / conservation.

It is also important to understand that the useful capacity is not the advertised one, but only the one of the bottom tank: the advertised capacity of 2.4 litres for the most common models contains only 1.4 litres, but rather takes up a good 3 litres of volume in your fridge, which usually does not have a dedicated filtering carafe space.

Let's talk about trace elements and carafe filters

But let's talk about trace elements, especially calcium and magnesium.

A carafe filter strongly reduces calcium, by about 80 to 90% thanks to the white resin beads, it is a fact in their leaflet.

Calcium and magnesium are essential to our good health, and certainly not responsible for kidney stones. We buy mineral water at 30 cents a bottle for its calcium and magnesium content, or cheese, or milk, why not drink the one that comes to us?

Moreover, to reduce the calcium, these products replace it with sodium, and thus result in a saltier water. So you have to be careful if you have excess salt in your body or a particular diet to follow.

So, yes, it is a fact that a carafe filter also reduces chlorine in the same proportions, and this is probably the first reason for its use.

But, according to Ances, it produces acidic water, the pH goes from 7.5 to 6, and becomes corrosive to metals. In fact, a spoonful of citric acid effectively cleans limes for 2€ per kg, but in reality, you will not restore the corroded metal of your kettle, which will corrode and then break through if you boil it with acidic and salty water too often. Therefore, it is not recommended to use filtered water in household appliances that heat water in metal: kettles, coffee machines, etc..

An alternative to the carafe filter... without filter!

bouteille purificatrice d'eau LaVie pure

LaVie UV-A water purifiers® work without filters or maintenance and allow you to purify your tap water in 15 minutes.

They use an innovative technology, patented and exclusive to LaVie®: the photolysis of chlorine by UV-A radiation.

This treatment allows the removal of chlorine and its derivatives, chemical compounds such as certain pesticides or traces of medication, and tastes and odours that can be found in tap water.

The result, which is very qualitative, makes it possible to draw a definitive line on the consumption of water in plastic bottles.

The carbon footprint linked to the manufacture of the aluminium tube of the UV water purifier is neutralised in a few days of use compared to the equivalent consumption of water in plastic bottles.

What about the bacteria in the filtering carafes?

The last point is bacteriological. The UFC que choisir and the ANSES warn after analyses on "nests of bacteria" measured in the daily use of filtering carafes.

With this information, you can choose your water purifier with precision, according to your needs and uses.

Our sources

QUE CHOISIR : Carafes filtering Useless, even worse !

NOTICE of the Anses relating to the Evaluation of the harmlessness and the effectiveness of the filtering carafes

Leave a comment

Please note, comments must be approved before they are published